Article VIII.
Judicial Department

Section 2. Supreme Court - Chief Justice - Declaring Law Unconstitutional - Justice Unable to Participate

Select dates to read amendment and select a date from the dropdown to compare the changes.

Supreme Court - Chief Justice - Declaring Law Unconstitutional - Justice Unable to Participate

The supreme court shall be the highest court and shall consist of at least five justices. The number of justices may be changed by statute, but no change shall have the effect of removing a justice from office. A chief justice shall be selected from among the justices of the supreme court as provided by statute. The chief justice may resign as chief justice without resigning from the supreme court. The supreme court by rule may sit and render final judgment either en banc or in divisions. The court shall not declare any law unconstitutional under this constitution or the Constitution of the United States, except on the concurrence of a majority of all justices of the supreme court. If a justice of the supreme court is disqualified or otherwise unable to participate in a cause before the court, the chief justice, or in the event the chief justice is disqualified or unable to participate, the remaining justices, shall call an active judge from an appellate court or the district court to participate in the cause.

Supreme Court, How Constituted - Terms

The supreme court shall consist of five judges, which number may be increased or decreased by the legislature, but no alteration or increase shall have the effect of removing a judge from office. A majority of the judges constituting the court shall be necessary to form a quorum or render a decision. If a justice of the supreme court shall be disqualified from sitting in a cause before said court, the remaining judges shall call a district judge to sit with them on the hearing of such cause. Every judge of the supreme court shall be at least thirty years of age, an active member of the bar, in good standing, learned in the law, and a resident of the state of Utah for the five years next preceding his selection. The judge having the shortest term to serve, not holding his office by selection to fill a vacancy before expiration of a regular term, shall be the chief justice, and shall preside at all terms of the supreme court, and in case of his absence, the judge, having in like manner, the next shortest term, shall preside in his stead.

Supreme Court, How Constituted - Terms

The Supreme Court shall consist of three Judges; but after the year A. D. 1905, the Legislature may increase the number thereof to five. A majority of the Judges constituting the court shall be necessary to form a quorum or render a decision. If a Justice of the Supreme Court shall be disqualified from sitting in a cause before said court, the remaining Judges shall call a District Judge to sit with them on the hearing of such cause. The Judges of the Supreme Court shall be elected by the electors of the State at large. The term of office of the Judges of the Supreme Court, excepting as in this article otherwise provided, shall be six years. The Judges of the Supreme Court, immediately after the first election under this Constitution, shall be selected by lot, so that one shall hold office for the term of three years, one for the term of five years, and one for the term of seven years. The lots shall be drawn by the Judges of the Supreme Court, who, for that purpose, shall assemble at the seat of government; and they shall cause the result thereof to be certified by the Secretary of State, and filed in his office. The Judge having the shortest term to serve, not holding his office by appointment or election to fill a vacancy, shall be the Chief Justice, and shall preside at all terms of the Supreme Court, and in case of his absence, the Judge, having in like manner, the next shortest term, shall preside in his stead.